packbat: A bat wearing a big asexual-flag (black-gray-white-purple) backpack. (efw random troll)
packbat ([personal profile] packbat) wrote2007-08-18 03:49 pm
Entry tags:

Alchemi Prompts: Pop Culture

What is something in pop culture (a commercial, a magazine, a trend, a common idea) that you particularly hate? Why?


Hate it? Not really - I actually kinda enjoy it. Nevertheless, it is pernicious.

It's the idea that Mom would sum up as "Neo, You're the One".

However, The Matrix is hardly the sole offender. It is probably an ancient storyline, to tell the truth. The protagonist (it's generally the protagonist), out of the blue, discovers that (I shall avoid the pronoun, though it is usually "he") is actually Special, and can, without or with minimal preparation, perform incredible, unheard of feats.

Just out of the blue. Bam. Wins the lottery. Bull.

Einstein didn't wake up one morning and build the atomic bomb, or prove the theory of relativity, or even demonstrate the photoelectric effect's dependence on the color of light. These are all things that took years to do, and were only accomplished at all through his familiarity with centuries of difficult work that preceded his, and the hard work of anything from dozens to thousands of other brilliant people. Jascha Heifetz is said to have practiced the violin at least three hours a day even when he was in his 80's. Mozart? Composed his first pieces when he was five - implying he didn't make the big time until he'd been working at it twenty years.

How many lottery winners can you name?

It's a stupid thing to be annoyed by. And, like I said, I like many of those stories, not all of which possessed even as much literary merit as The Matrix has. But wish fulfillment is no virtue.

[identity profile] chanlemur.livejournal.com 2007-08-19 11:23 pm (UTC)(link)
I think there is a healthy measure of wish-gratification here, yes; but on another level, it's the neatest way to work out a particularly thorny metafictional tangle, to wit:

1. A huge and overpowering antagonist force is often critical to drive the excitement of a plot.

2. A humble, average protagonist is often critical to the audience's ability to sympathize with him/her.

3. Yet, despite this obvious power disparity, #2 must somehow triumph over #1.

How do we do this? Magic plot twist! Give the seed of the enemy's destruction to #2. In short, Neo's being The One is little different from Frodo Baggins inheriting the One Ring from Uncle Bilbo. It's just that there's a lot more kung fu going on in the former case.

[identity profile] packbat.livejournal.com 2007-08-20 09:13 am (UTC)(link)
Well, I suppose there's that. I generally prefer fast-witted though undersupplied protagonists, personally. Like the one in the Sheri S. Tepper book who knocked an assassin over a staircase (or something, not sure) but ducked back into her room fast enough that she could pretend to have been awoken by the crash.